Stephen A. Smith lashes out at Jaxson Dart and his risky behavior with the Giants

Stephen A. Smith launched strong criticisms against Jaxson Dart following the New York Giants’ latest defeat, sparking intense debate about the young quarterback’s future.

The concern is not just about on-field results, but also about decisions that could put his career and the team’s stability in the NFL at risk.

Stephen A. Smith warning

On ESPN’s First Take, Stephen A. Smith did not hesitate to call out the rookie’s mistakes. After five concussion evaluations this season, Smith questioned Dart’s approach to the risks he faces on the field.

“I think his attitude is completely wrong. He doesn’t understand the importance of surviving and living to play another snap,” the commentator stated, making it clear that talent alone is not enough.

According to Stephen A. Smith, intelligence and awareness are just as essential as courage on the field.

Dart, who assumed the QB1 role after a disappointing start with Russell Wilson, has shown potential with 1,802 passing yards and 13 passing touchdowns, plus 400 rushing yards and seven rushing touchdowns.

However, his repeated exposure to unnecessary hits raises concern both for the organization and sports health experts.

“You’re in a man’s game now. You are a rookie, and you have already been in concussion protocol five times.”@stephenasmith on Jaxson Dart’s reaction to being examined for a concussion in the Giants Week 15 loss to the Commanders ✍️ pic.twitter.com/iFft0u2Rp7

— First Take (@FirstTake) December 16, 2025

Doubts and possible changes in the Giants

Stephen A. Smith critique adds to the uncertainty surrounding the New York franchise. With a 2-12 record and an eight-game losing streak, the Giants could secure the first overall pick in the next draft, opening the possibility of adding another quarterback and increasing competition for Dart.

Evan Roberts, a Giants analyst, warns that decisions about the QB’s future could depend on external factors, not just his performance.

Furthermore, Stephen A. Smith emphasizes that a player like Dart has responsibilities not only to himself but also to his teammates and the organization, which need him to be in optimal condition to compete.

This season has shown that, despite obvious talent, survival on the field is crucial to building a solid NFL career.

For now, Stephen A. Smith keeps a close eye on Dart, generating intrigue over whether the young quarterback will learn to balance bravery with prudence.