Lamar Jackson and the label that divides NFL experts

Lamar Jackson is once again at the center of NFL conversations, but not for his impressive skills—instead, for a controversy that threatens to overshadow his legacy.

Before the crucial divisional game between the Baltimore Ravens and the Cleveland Browns, the quarterback faced harsh criticism. A well-known journalist and scout labeled him as “the most overrated quarterback in the NFL.”

Statistics vs. perception: The Lamar Jackson dilemma

Unless one examines his numbers closely, it’s hard to call Lamar Jackson overrated, especially considering his two NFL MVP awards.

However, Alex Kay of Bleacher Report didn’t hesitate to place him at the top of his list of overrated quarterbacks, even calling him the most overrated of all time.

The issue, according to critics, isn’t his regular-season performance. Lamar Jackson posts impressive stats year after year, and his team generally performs at a competitive level when he’s on the field.

Wow: Bleacher Report has named Ravens QB Lamar Jackson the most overrated QB in the NFL.

“[He] may not just be one of today’s most overrated active quarterbacks, but also of all time…His 2-time MVP status is borderline fraudulent. His credentials don’t measure up to other… pic.twitter.com/GABheAhbxi

— Dov Kleiman (@NFL_DovKleiman) November 13, 2025

The real controversy emerges in high-stakes moments, Jackson has reached the AFC Championship game only once in eight attempts, and his 3-5 playoff record, with a .375 winning percentage. Raises doubts about his ability to lead his team in critical situations.

Between criticism and comeback: Jackson impact on the Ravens

Despite the critiques, Lamar Jackson proves his influence cannot be underestimated. The Baltimore Ravens suffered four consecutive losses while the quarterback was recovering from an injury in 2025. And his return revitalized the team, sparking three straight wins.

This shows that, even if his postseason performance is questioned, his presence remains key to the team’s competitiveness.

The tension surrounding Lamar Jackson reflects not only his standing in the NFL but also how perceptions of a player can swing between admiration and controversy.

While fans and analysts debate whether he’s truly overrated, Jackson remains an inevitable protagonist in the Ravens’ narrative. Where every win or loss is scrutinized.

With his undeniable talent and the shadow of criticism over his career. Lamar Jackson faces a season that could redefine his legacy, both on and off the field.