Aaron Rodgers faces criticism from Skip Bayless after the loss to the Bills

Aaron Rodgers joined the Pittsburgh Steelers hoping to revive a franchise eager to return to the playoffs, but the 26-7 loss to the Buffalo Bills in Week 13 raised more questions than answers about his physical condition and performance.

The 41-year-old veteran quarterback, a four-time regular-season MVP, once again showed the cumulative effects of his career in a game many are calling a warning about the fragility of his final stage in the NFL.

Aaron Rodgers under pressure: Alarming statistics

Aaron Rodgers had a tough day against a Bills defense that exploited every lapse.

A fumble caused by Christian Benford highlighted the quarterback’s vulnerability and sparked criticism from figures like Skip Bayless, who said Rodgers appeared “worn out and washed up.”

The statistics back up this perception: his average of 189.6 passing yards per game is his lowest since 2007, and his QBR of 44.2 before Week 13 is the worst in over a decade, including his last stint with Green Bay.

The Pittsburgh Steelers are now 6-6, tied with the Ravens, two games ahead of the Bengals. Aaron Rodgers is battered and washed. Joe Burrow’s Bengals are going to win the AFC N.

— Skip Bayless (@RealSkipBayless) December 1, 2025

Pittsburgh now faces the real possibility of missing the playoffs for the first time since 2022, and fans are debating whether the Rodgers era alongside Mike Tomlin should come to an end—or if there is still room for a resurgence.

Rodgers resilience and legacy on the line

Despite the criticism and declining numbers, Aaron Rodgers showed character by finishing the game after returning from a left wrist injury.

His willingness to endure pressure and continue leading the team reflects the courage that has defined his career and will ultimately earn him a place in the Hall of Fame.

Rodgers remains a central figure in Pittsburgh, and while recent results have sparked controversy, his experience and leadership still offer a glimmer of hope for the Steelers.

Every game becomes a test of resilience for both him and the franchise as the NFL watches closely to see if this veteran can overcome the passage of time—or if his era is approaching its inevitable conclusion.