Travis Hunter sidelined by injury: has the NFL shut the door on the two-way dream?

Travis Hunter’s rookie campaign with the Jacksonville Jaguars came to an abrupt end. The young standout, taken second overall in the 2025 NFL Draft, underwent surgery to repair a lateral collateral ligament (LCL) injury in his knee. He’s expected to be out for at least six months. The news was confirmed by Ian Rapoport and reported by sports outlet Firstsportz.

Travis Hunter entered the league with a bold proposition: to play both wide receiver and cornerback, echoing the two-way role that made him a sensation at Colorado under Deion Sanders. In his first seven games, Hunter flashed his potential—especially as a receiver. Week 7 was his breakout moment, racking up 101 yards and scoring his first professional touchdown. But a practice injury during the bye week changed everything.

Sources: #Jaguars star CB/WR Travis Hunter underwent season-ending knee surgery, with eyes set on 2026. It was an LCL repair.

He’s expected to return within 6 months to full football activities. pic.twitter.com/nFEnZad6rU

— Ian Rapoport (@RapSheet) November 11, 2025

A serious setback

Medical staff in Dallas confirmed the severity of the injury and performed the surgery. While a full recovery is expected, the impact on Travis Hunter’s rookie development is undeniable. His absence affects the Jaguars’ depth and strategy, but more importantly, it reignites the debate over whether a two-way role is sustainable in the NFL.

Analysts like ESPN’s Marcus Spears have voiced skepticism. In recent comments, Spears warned that the physical toll of playing both offense and defense could lead to recurring injuries—especially for someone with Travis Hunter’s frame. “If you’re going to play both sides in the NFL, you’re going to miss significant time due to injury,” said the former defensive lineman.

A divided fanbase

Social media lit up with mixed reactions. Some fans believe Travis Hunter’s attempt to replicate his college success came too soon. Others defend his versatility, calling it a strategic asset that should be nurtured and managed carefully. The truth is, the NFL isn’t a playground for experiments. And Hunter’s case may set a precedent for future two-way hopefuls.

I think that playing both ways 65-80 snaps thing is done. He didn’t even last half a season. Todays NFL is hard enough doing one position.

— Tommy Dennis (@TommyDennis) November 11, 2025

The human body can only handle so much. Hunter needs to choose either WR or CB, but perhaps could go to either side for ONE play occasionally when needed. Hopefully he will make a full recovery. It’s a big blow for the Jaguars.

— Dennis Gursky (@Dgursky65) November 11, 2025

Despite the setback, the Jaguars remain committed to their young star. His recovery will be pivotal in determining whether Travis Hunter continues as a dual-threat athlete or focuses on a single position. For now, he faces a demanding rehab process with his sights set on returning stronger in 2026.