Former running back and analyst LeSean McCoy didn’t hold back. He recently criticized Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa following the team’s crushing 31-6 defeat against the Cleveland Browns. Week 7 turned out to be disastrous for the franchise, and all the pressure fell on their quarterback.
Tagovailoa has delivered inconsistent performances throughout the season. Despite this, the Dolphins gave him a four-year, $212.4 million extension, which includes $167 million guaranteed.
It’s time to make a decision
According to The Sports Rush, McCoy stressed that Tua has not proven himself as an elite quarterback. The stats support his claim: Tua threw three interceptions and completed only 12 of 23 passes for 100 yards.
🎥 LeSean McCoy on Tua Tagovailoa: “He plays super soft in the cold, he got little arms… and you always got an excuse. I never seen a QB go up and you played shit*y all game and then you get at the podium and you blaming everyone else.” (@speakeasytlkshw) #PhinsUp pic.twitter.com/DBd9r3YpKn
— FinsXtra (@FinsXtra) October 20, 2025
McCoy believes that the absence of stars like Tyreek Hill exposed Tua’s limitations. He also highlighted that the Dolphins’ attempts to trade for Tom Brady or Deshaun Watson reflect a lack of confidence in their quarterback. The analyst even suggested that rookie quarterback Quinn Ewers should replace Tua in upcoming games so the team can properly assess its future options.
McCoy also criticized the Dolphins’ decision to re-sign Tua. He remarked, “I couldn’t believe they’re paying him so much,” referring to Tua’s injuries and underwhelming performance.
McCoy’s analysis clearly illustrates that, in his view, the Dolphins face a delicate situation. The team must make critical decisions regarding their star quarterback to avoid jeopardizing the season and to plan for the future. The pressure on Tua has never been greater, and the Dolphins must determine whether they trust him to lead the team or if they should invest in new talent.
Ultimately, McCoy’s comments underscore the growing tension around the Dolphins’ quarterback situation. Fans and analysts alike are watching closely, as the team navigates a pivotal moment in its season and evaluates the path forward for its franchise quarterback.
