Comparison and division
The comparison sparked plenty of discussion. Analysts, fans, and former NFL players are split. ESPN regular Dan Orlovsky backed the notion that Jalen Hurts is the main roadblock to the Super Bowl from the NFC. A sort of “new wall” teams will have to get past to lift the Lombardi Trophy.
And the conversation doesn’t end there. Eagles legend Donovan McNabb suggested that Jalen Hurts could be even more productive if he were freed from Kellen Moore’s offensive framework. According to McNabb, Philadelphia hasn’t yet tapped fully into everything Jalen Hurts can offer, hinting at explosive potential for the coming season. These views leave Josh Allen largely outside the spotlight.
On another front, Manti Te’o stepped up to defend the “system player” label that some use to downplay Jalen Hurts. To him, it’s not a weakness—it’s a strength. “Hurts is a Porsche, and the Eagles know how to drive it.” Style and horsepower, perfectly tuned.
Power and a strong season
As for Josh Allen, he remains a powerful force with a cannon for an arm. In 2024, he threw for over 4,500 yards and stacked more than 40 total touchdowns. His style is more aggressive and less structured, turning him into a weekly spectacle. Still, the absence of a Super Bowl appearance continues to weigh on his narrative against Jalen Hurts.
With just weeks to go before the 2025 season kicks off, the debate isn’t just about stats anymore. Jalen Hurts has already shown he can shine when the lights are hottest. Josh Allen still has time to prove he can do the same, but every snap—and every opinion—adds fuel to this quietly blazing rivalry.
